LD_LIBRARY_PATH - just say no
By user12613883 on Jul 10, 2004
A recent email discussion reminded me of how fragile, and prevalent, LD_LIBRARY_PATH use it. Within a development environment, this variable is very useful. I use it all the time to experiment with new libraries. But within a production environment, use of this environment variable can be problematic. See Directories Searched by the Runtime Linker for an overview of LD_LIBRARY_PATH use at runtime.
People use this environment variable to establish search paths for applications whose dependencies do not reside in constant locations.
Sometimes wrapper scripts are employed to set this variable,
other times users maintain an LD_LIBRARY_PATH within their
% ldd -s /usr/bin/date ... find object=libc.so.1; required by /usr/bin/date search path=/opt/ISV/lib (LD_LIBRARY_PATH)
If you have a large number of LD_LIBRARY_PATH components specified,
Wrapper scripts attempt to compensate for inherited LD_LIBRARY_PATH use. For example, a version of acroread reveals:
LD_LIBRARY_PATH="`prepend "$ACRO_INSTALL_DIR/$ACRO_CONFIG/lib:\\ $ACRO_INSTALL_DIR/$ACRO_CONFIG/lib" "$LD_LIBRARY_PATH"`
The script is prepending its LD_LIBRARY_PATH requirement to any inherited definition. Although this provides the necessary environment for acroread to execute, we're still wasting time looking for any system libraries in the acroread sub-directories.
When 64-bit binaries came along, we had a bit of a dilemma with how to interpret LD_LIBRARY_PATH. But, because of its popularity, it was decided to leave it applicable to both class of binaries (64 and 32-bit), even though its unusual for a directory to contain both 64 and 32-bit dependencies. We also added LD_LIBRARY_PATH_64 and LD_LIBRARY_PATH_32 as a means of specifying search paths that are specific to a class of objects. These class specific environment variables are used instead of any generic LD_LIBRARY_PATH setting.
Which leads me back to the recent email discussion. Seems a customer was setting both the _64 and _32 variables as part of their startup script, because both 64 and 32 bit processes could be spawned. However, one spawned process was acroread. Its LD_LIBRARY_PATH setting was being overridden by the _32 variable, and hence it failed to execute. Sigh.
Is there a solution to this mess? I guess we could keep bashing
LD_LIBRARY_PATH into submission some way, but why not get
rid of the LD_LIBRARY_PATH requirement altogether? This
can be done. Applications and dependencies can be built to include
a runpath using
Is there a limitation to $ORIGIN use? Yes, as directed by the security folks, expansion of this token is not allowed for secure applications. But then again, for secure applications, LD_LIBRARY_PATH components are ignored for non-secure directories anyway. See Security.
For a flexible mechanism of finding dependencies, use a runpath that includes the $ORIGIN token, and try not to create secure applications :-)