Wednesday Oct 14, 2009
Sunday May 11, 2008
By John Morrison on May 11, 2008
Where are the bulk of your test efforts focused on ? Am sure most testing teams would be focused on testing a product's functionality or at least a majority of the time spent in testing could be involved in testing for the functional requirements; which is not a bad thing at all ! But, how much focus is given to testing the non-functional requirements, assuming there are a set of well defined non-functional requirements and the same has been suitably incorporated into the product and tests have been developed for verifying the same.
What are the common non-functional requirements and why do we need to even spend time talking of them let alone have specialized resources dedicated and assigned to test them ? Put it simply, assuming a condition of cetirus paribus (all other things being equal and similar functional features in two competing products), non-functional requirements often play a significant role in differentiating between a product that is well received by customers vs one that may not do well in the market place. Some of the key non-functional requirements include Usability, Performance, Security, Interoperability & Compatibility.
While common reasoning states that a product that does not meet its functional requirements is incomplete, do we do the same for the non-functional requirements too or do we agree to address non-functional requirements / issues found in an upcoming patch or subsequent release? However, this line of thinking exposes the chinks in the armor when the product is being deployed at the customer site or when it is moved to production. A product that is'nt suitably performance tested and does not meet well laid out performance criterion, could fail miserably in a production deployment. Similarly with other items such as security, usability or compatibility. It is'nt hard to visualize the impact each of these non-functional items can have in a real usage scenario.
Non-functional risks need to be evaluated and considered during project planning. During requirements phase, both functional and non-functional requirements need to be spelt out and considered by both development and testing teams. Also, meeting non-functional requirements does involve a certain degree of trade-offs and arriving at a suitable balance between focusing on non-functional requirements vs. other areas of the product is needed.