Fake vs. True Sharing
By MortazaviBlog on Dec 01, 2006
Lawrence Lessig writes about fake vs. true sharing.
The fact that Lessig has to use an adjective to qualify sharing may be another proof of how little words have come to mean in common usage. You cannot be said to be sharing your bread unless the party you're sharing it with can also eat from the part that has been shared. Otherwise, you're only sharing the right to watch the bread, not any rights to eat from it.
Much of the videos posted on YouTube are posted with an intention to
share them completely. Users should be able to copy and mix such video quite freely. As Lessig has noted, disputes regarding this model continue.
A sharing that doesn't grant any independent use rights can hardly be called sharing.