Friday Mar 20, 2015

Oracle ZFS Storage ZS4-4 Shows 1.8x Generational Performance Improvement on SPC-2 Benchmark

The Oracle ZFS Storage ZS4-4 appliance delivered 1.8x improved performance and 1.3x improved price performance over the previous generation Oracle ZFS Storage ZS3-4 appliance as shown by the SPC-2 benchmark.

  • Running the SPC-2 benchmark, the Oracle ZFS Storage ZS4-4 appliance delivered SPC-2 Price-Performance of $17.09 and an overall score of 31,486.23 SPC-2 MBPS.

  • The Oracle ZFS Storage continues its strong price performance by occupying the three of the top five SPC-2 price performance.

  • Oracle holds the three of the top four performance results on the SPC-2 benchmark for HDD based systems.

  • The Oracle ZFS Storage ZS4-4 appliance has a 7.6x price-performance advantage over the IBM DS8870 and 2x performance advantage as measured by the SPC-2 benchmark.

  • The Oracle ZFS Storage ZS4-4 appliance has a 5.0x performance advantage over the new Fujitsu DX200 S3 as measured by the SPC-2 benchmark.

  • The Oracle ZFS Storage ZS4-4 appliance has a 4.6x price-performance advantage over the Fujitsu ET8700 S2 and 1.9x performance advantage as shown by the SPC-2 benchmark.

  • The Oracle ZFS Storage ZS4-4 appliance has a 4.6x price-performance advantage over the Hitachi Virtual Storage Platform (VSP) and 1.96x performance advantage as measured by the SPC-2 benchmark.

  • The Oracle ZFS Storage ZS4-4 appliance has a 1.6x price-performance advantage over the HP XP7 disk array as shown by the SPC-2 benchmark (HP even discounted their hardware 63%).

Performance Landscape

SPC-2 Price-Performance

Below is a table of the top SPC-2 Price-Performance results for HDD storage based systems, presented in increasing price-performance order (as of 03/17/2015). The complete set of results may be found at SPC2 top 10 Price-Performance list.

System SPC-2
MBPS
$/SPC-2
MBPS
Results
Identifier
Oracle ZFS Storage ZS3-2 16,212.66 $12.08 BE00002
Fujitsu Eternus DX200 S3 6,266.50 $15.42 B00071
SGI InfiniteStorage 5600 8,855.70 $15.97 B00065
Oracle ZFS Storage ZS4-4 31,486.23 $17.09 B00072
Oracle ZFS Storage ZS3-4 17,244.22 $22.53 B00067
NEC Storage M700 14,408.89 $25.10 B00066
Sun StorageTek 2530 663.51 $26.48 B00026
HP XP7 storage 43,012.53 $28.30 B00070
Fujitsu ETERNUS DX80 S2 2,685.50 $28.48 B00055
SGI InfiniteStorage 5500-SP 4,064.49 $28.57 B00059
Hitachi Unified Storage VM 11,274.83 $32.64 B00069

SPC-2 MBPS = the Performance Metric
$/SPC-2 MBPS = the Price-Performance Metric
Results Identifier = A unique identification of the result

SPC-2 Performance

The following table list the top SPC-2 -Performance results for HDD storage based systems, presented in decreasing performance order (as of 03/17/2015). The complete set of results may be found at the SPC2 top 10 Performance list.

HDD Based Systems SPC-2
MBPS
$/SPC-2
MBPS
TSC Price Results
Identifier
HP XP7 storage 43,012.52 $28.30 $1,217,462 B00070
Oracle ZFS Storage ZS4-4 31,486.23 $17.09 $538,050 B00072
Oracle ZFS Storage ZS3-4 17,244.22 $22.53 $388,472 B00067
Oracle ZFS Storage ZS3-2 16,212.66 $12.08 $195,915 BE00002
Fujitsu ETERNUS DX8870 S2 16,038.74 $79.51 $1,275,163 B00063
IBM System Storage DS8870 15,423.66 $131.21 $2,023,742 B00062
IBM SAN VC v6.4 14,581.03 $129.14 $1,883,037 B00061
Hitachi Virtual Storage Platform (VSP) 13,147.87 $95.38 $1,254,093 B00060
HP StorageWorks P9500 XP Storage Array 13,147.87 $88.34 $1,161,504 B00056

SPC-2 MBPS = the Performance Metric
$/SPC-2 MBPS = the Price-Performance Metric
TSC Price = Total Cost of Ownership Metric
Results Identifier = A unique identification of the result Metric

Complete SPC-2 benchmark results may be found at
http://www.storageperformance.org/results/benchmark_results_spc2.

Configuration Summary

Storage Configuration:

Oracle ZFS Storage ZS4-4 storage system in clustered configuration
2 x Oracle ZFS Storage ZS4-4 controllers with
8 x Intel Xeon processors
3 TB memory
24 x Oracle Storage Drive Enclosure DE2-24P, each with
24 x 300 GB 10K RPM SAS-2 drives

Benchmark Description

SPC Benchmark 2 (SPC-2): Consists of three distinct workloads designed to demonstrate the performance of a storage subsystem during the execution of business critical applications that require the large-scale, sequential movement of data. Those applications are characterized predominately by large I/Os organized into one or more concurrent sequential patterns. A description of each of the three SPC-2 workloads is listed below as well as examples of applications characterized by each workload.

  • Large File Processing: Applications in a wide range of fields, which require simple sequential process of one or more large files such as scientific computing and large-scale financial processing.
  • Large Database Queries: Applications that involve scans or joins of large relational tables, such as those performed for data mining or business intelligence.
  • Video on Demand: Applications that provide individualized video entertainment to a community of subscribers by drawing from a digital film library.

SPC-2 is built to:

  • Provide a level playing field for test sponsors.
  • Produce results that are powerful and yet simple to use.
  • Provide value for engineers as well as IT consumers and solution integrators.
  • Is easy to run, easy to audit/verify, and easy to use to report official results.

See Also

Disclosure Statement

SPC-2 and SPC-2 MBPS are registered trademarks of Storage Performance Council (SPC). Results as of March 17, 2015, for more information see www.storageperformance.org.

Oracle ZFS Storage ZS4-4 - B00072, Oracle ZFS Storage ZS3-2 - BE00002, Oracle ZFS Storage ZS3-4 - B00067, Fujitsu ETERNUS DX80 S2, B00055, Fujitsu ETERNUS DX8870 S2 - B00063, Fujitsu ETERNUS DX200 S3 - B00071, HP StorageWorks P9500 XP Storage Array - B00056, HP XP7 Storage Array - B00070, Hitachi Unified Storage VM - B00069, Hitachi Virtual Storage Platform (VSP) - B00060, IBM SAN VC v6.4 - B00061, IBM System Storage DS8870 - B00062, IBM XIV Storage System Gen3 - BE00001, NEC Storage M700 - B00066, SGI InfiniteStorage 5500-SP - B00059, SGI InfiniteStorage 5600 - B00065, Sun StorageTek 2530 - B00026.

Wednesday Jun 25, 2014

Oracle ZFS Storage ZS3-2 Delivers World Record Price-Performance on SPC-2/E

The Oracle ZFS Storage ZS3-2 appliance delivered a world record Price-Performance result, world record energy result and excellent overall performance for the SPC-2/E benchmark.

  • The Oracle ZFS Storage ZS3-2 appliance delivered the top SPC-2 Price-Performance of $12.08 and it delivered an overall score of 16,212.66 SPC-2 MBPS for the SPC-2/E benchmark.

  • The Oracle ZFS Storage ZS3-2 appliance produced the top Performance-Energy SPC-2/E benchmark result of 3.67 SPC2 MBPS / watt.

  • Oracle holds the top two performance results on the SPC-2 benchmark for HDD based systems.

  • The Oracle ZFS Storage ZS3-2 appliance has an 11x price-performance advantage over the IBM DS8870.

  • The Oracle ZFS Storage ZS3-2 appliance has an 8x price-performance advantage over the Hitachi Virtual Storage Platform (VSP).

  • The Oracle ZFS Storage ZS3-2 appliance has an 7.3x price-performance advantage over the HP P9500 XP disk array.

Performance Landscape

SPC-2 Price-Performance

Below is a table of the top SPC-2 Price-Performance results for HDD storage based systems, presented in increasing price-performance order (as of 06/25/2014). The complete set of results may be found at SPC2 top 10 Price-Performance list.

System SPC-2
MBPS
$/SPC-2
MBPS
Results
Identifier
Oracle ZFS Storage ZS3-2 16,212.66 $12.08 BE00002
SGI InfiniteStorage 5600 8,855.70 $15.97 B00065
Oracle ZFS Storage ZS3-4 17,244.22 $22.53 B00067
NEC Storage M700 14,408.89 $25.10 B00066
Sun StorageTek 2530 663.51 $26.48 B00026
Fujitsu ETERNUS DX80 S2 2,685.50 $28.48 B00055
SGI InfiniteStorage 5500-SP 4,064.49 $28.57 B00059
Hitachi Unified Storage VM 11,274.83 $32.64 B00069

SPC-2 MBPS = the Performance Metric
$/SPC-2 MBPS = the Price-Performance Metric
Results Identifier = A unique identification of the result

SPC-2/E Results

The table below list all SPC-2/E results. The SPC-2/E benchmark extends the SPC-2 benchmark by additionally measuring power consumption during the SPC-2 benchmark run.

System SPC-2
MBPS
$/SPC-2
MBPS
TSC Price SPC2 MBPS /
watt
Results
Identifier
Oracle ZFS Storage ZS3-2 16,212.66 $12.08 $195,915 3.67 BE00002
IBM XIV Storage System Gen3 7,467.99 $152.34 $1,137,641 0.81 BE00001

SPC-2 MBPS = the Performance Metric
$/SPC-2 MBPS = the Price-Performance Metric
TSC Price = Total Cost of Ownership Metric
SPC2 MBPS / watt = Number of SPC2 MB/second produced per watt consumed. Higher is Better.
Results Identifier = A unique identification of the result

SPC-2 Performance

The following table list the top SPC-2 -Performance results for HDD storage based systems, presented in decreasing performance order (as of 06/25/2014). The complete set of results may be found at the SPC2 top 10 Performance list.

System SPC-2
MBPS
$/SPC-2
MBPS
TSC Price Results
Identifier
Oracle ZFS Storage ZS3-4 17,244.22 $22.53 $388,472 B00067
Oracle ZFS Storage ZS3-2 16,212.66 $12.08 $195,915 BE00002
Fujitsu ETERNUS DX8870 S2 16,038.74 $79.51 $1,275,163 B00063
IBM System Storage DS8870 15,423.66 $131.21 $2,023,742 B00062
IBM SAN VC v6.4 14,581.03 $129.14 $1,883,037 B00061
Hitachi Virtual Storage Platform (VSP) 13,147.87 $95.38 $1,254,093 B00060
HP StorageWorks P9500 XP Storage Array 13,147.87 $88.34 $1,161,504 B00056

SPC-2 MBPS = the Performance Metric
$/SPC-2 MBPS = the Price-Performance Metric
TSC Price = Total Cost of Ownership Metric
Results Identifier = A unique identification of the result Metric

Complete SPC-2 benchmark results may be found at
http://www.storageperformance.org/results/benchmark_results_spc2.

Configuration Summary

Storage Configuration:

Oracle ZFS Storage ZS3-2 storage system in clustered configuration
2 x Oracle ZFS Storage ZS3-2 controllers, each with
4 x 2.1 GHz 8-core Intel Xeon processors
512 GB memory
12 x Sun Disk shelves, each with
24 x 300 GB 10K RPM SAS-2 drives

Benchmark Description

SPC Benchmark 2 (SPC-2): Consists of three distinct workloads designed to demonstrate the performance of a storage subsystem during the execution of business critical applications that require the large-scale, sequential movement of data. Those applications are characterized predominately by large I/Os organized into one or more concurrent sequential patterns. A description of each of the three SPC-2 workloads is listed below as well as examples of applications characterized by each workload.

  • Large File Processing: Applications in a wide range of fields, which require simple sequential process of one or more large files such as scientific computing and large-scale financial processing.
  • Large Database Queries: Applications that involve scans or joins of large relational tables, such as those performed for data mining or business intelligence.
  • Video on Demand: Applications that provide individualized video entertainment to a community of subscribers by drawing from a digital film library.

SPC-2 is built to:

  • Provide a level playing field for test sponsors.
  • Produce results that are powerful and yet simple to use.
  • Provide value for engineers as well as IT consumers and solution integrators.
  • Is easy to run, easy to audit/verify, and easy to use to report official results.

SPC Benchmark 2/Energy (SPC-2/E): consists of the complete set of SPC-2 performance measurement and reporting plus the measurement and reporting of energy use. This benchmark extension provides measurement and reporting to complete storage configurations, complementing SPC-2C/E, which focuses on storage component configurations.

See Also

Disclosure Statement

SPC-2 and SPC-2 MBPS are registered trademarks of Storage Performance Council (SPC). Results as of June 25, 2014, for more information see www.storageperformance.org.

Fujitsu ETERNUS DX80 S2, B00055, Fujitsu ETERNUS DX8870 S2 - B00063, HP StorageWorks P9500 XP Storage Array - B00056, Hitachi Unified Storage VM - B00069, Hitachi Virtual Storage Platform (VSP) - B00060, IBM SAN VC v6.4 - B00061, IBM System Storage DS8870 - B00062, IBM XIV Storage System Gen3 - BE00001, NEC Storage M700 - B00066, Oracle ZFS Storage ZS3-2 - BE00002, Oracle ZFS Storage ZS3-4 - B00067, SGI InfiniteStorage 5500-SP - B00059, SGI InfiniteStorage 5600 - B00065, Sun StorageTek 2530 - B00026.

Wednesday Oct 28, 2009

SPC-2 Sun Storage 6780 Array RAID 5 & RAID 6 51% better $/performance than IBM DS5300

Significance of Results

Results on the Sun Storage 6780 Array with 8Gb connectivity are presented for the SPC-2 benchmark using RAID 5 and RAID 6.
  • The Sun Storage 6780 array outperforms the IBM DS5300 by 51% in price performance for SPC-2 benchmark using RAID 5 data protection.

  • The Sun Storage 6780 array outperforms the IBM DS5300 by 51% in price performance for SPC-2 benchmark using RAID 6 data protection.

  • The Sun Storage 6780 Array has 62% better performance than the Fujitsu 800/1100 and delivers a price performance advantage of 5.6x as measured by the SPC-2 benchmark.

  • The Sun Storage 6800 array with 8Gb connectivity improved performance by 36% over the 4GB connected solution as measured by the SPC-2 benchmark.

Performance Landscape

SPC-2 Performance Chart (in increasing price-performance order)

Sponsor System SPC-2
MBPS
$/SPC-2
MBPS
ASU
Capacity
(GB)
TSC Price Data
Protection
Level
Date Results
Identifier
Sun SS6780 (8Gb) 5,634.17 $44.88 16,383.186 $252,873 RAID 5 10/27/09 B00047
IBM DS5300 (8Gb) 5,634.17 $67.75 16,383.186 $381,720 RAID 5 10/21/09 B00045
Sun SS6780 (8Gb) 5,543.88 $45.61 14,042.731 $252,873 RAID 6 10/27/09 B00048
IBM DS5300 (8Gb) 5,543.88 $68.85 14,042.731 $381,720 RAID 6 10/21/09 B00046
Sun SS6780 (4Gb) 4,818.43 $53.61 16,383.186 $258,329 RAID 5 02/03/09 B00039
IBM DS5300 (4Gb) 4,818.43 $93.80 16,383.186 $451,986 RAID 5 09/25/08 B00037
Sun SS6780 (4Gb) 4,675.50 $55.25 14,042.731 $258,329 RAID 6 02/03/09 B00040
IBM DS5300 (4Gb) 4,675.50 $96.67 14,042.731 $451,986 RAID 6 09/25/08 B00038
Fujitsu 800/1100 3,480.68 $238.93 4,569.845 $831,649 Mirroring 03/08/07 B00019

SPC-2 MBPS = the Performance Metric
$/SPC-2 MBPS = the Price/Performance Metric
ASU Capacity = the Capacity Metric
Data Protection = Data Protection Metric
TSC Price = Total Cost of Ownership Metric
Results Identifier = A unique identification of the result Metric

Complete SPC-2 benchmark results may be found at http://www.storageperformance.org.

Results and Configuration Summary

Storage Configuration:

    8 x CM200 trays, each with 16 x 146GB 15K RPM drives
    8 x Qlogic 8Gb HBA

Server Configuration:

    4 x IBM x3650
      2 x 2.93 GHz Intel X5570
      5 GB memory

Software Configuration:

    Microsoft Windows Server 2003 Enterprise Edition (32-bit) with SP2
    SPC-2 benchmark kit

Benchmark Description

The SPC Benchmark-2™ (SPC-2) is a series of related benchmark performance tests that simulate the sequential component of demands placed upon on-line, non-volatile storage in server class computer systems. SPC-2 provides measurements in support of real world environments characterized by:
  • Large numbers of concurrent sequential transfers.
  • Demanding data rate requirements, including requirements for real time processing.
  • Diverse application techniques for sequential processing.
  • Substantial storage capacity requirements.
  • Data persistence requirements to ensure preservation of data without corruption or loss.

Key Points and Best Practices

  • This benchmark was performed using RAID 5 and RAID 6 protection.
  • The controller stripe size was set to 512k.
  • No volume manager was used.

See Also

Benchmark Tags

$/Perf, performance, bandwidth, OpenStorage, Storage

Disclosure Statement

SPC-2, SPC-2 MBPS, $/SPC-2 MBPS are regular trademarks of Storage Performance Council (SPC). More info www.storageperformance.org. Sun Storage 6780 Array 5,634.17 SPC-2 MBPS, $/SPC-2 MBPS $44.88, ASU Capacity 16,838.186GB, Protect RAID 5, Cost $252,873.00, Ident. B00047. Sun Storage 6780 Array 5,543.88 SPC-2 MBPS, $/SPC-2 MBPS $45.61, ASU Capacity 14,042.731 GB, Protect RAID 6, Cost $252,873.00, Ident. B00048.

Publication Rules

See here for publication rules.

Monday Oct 12, 2009

SPC-2 Sun Storage 6180 Array RAID 5 & RAID 6 Over 70% Better Price Performance than IBM

Significance of Results

Results on the Sun Storage 6180 Array with 8Gb connectivity are presented for the SPC-2 benchmark using RAID 5 and RAID 6.
  • The Sun Storage 6180 Array outperforms the IBM DS5020 by 77% in price performance for SPC-2 benchmark using RAID 5 data protection.

  • The Sun Storage 6180 Array outperforms the IBM DS5020 by 91% in price performance for SPC-2 benchmark using RAID 6 data protection.

  • The Sun Storage 6180 Array is 50% faster than the previous generation, the Sun Storage 6140 Array and IBM DS4700 on the SPC-2 benchmark using RAID 5 data protection.

Performance Landscape

SPC-2 Performance Chart (in increasing price-performance order)

Sponsor System SPC-2 MBPS $/SPC-2 MBPS ASU Capacity (GB) TSC Price Data Protection Level Date Results Identifier
Sun SS6180 1,286.74 $45.47 3,504.693 $58,512 RAID 6 10/08/09 B00044
IBM DS5020 1,286.74 $87.04 3,504.693 $112,002 RAID 6 10/08/09 B00042
Sun SS6180 1,244.89 $42.53 3,504.693 $52,951 RAID 5 10/08/09 B00043
IBM DS5020 1,244.89 $75.30 3,504.693 $93,742 RAID 5 10/08/09 B00041
Sun J4400 887.44 $25.63 23,965.918 $22,742 unprotected 08/15/08 B00034
IBM DS4700 823.62 $106.73 1,748.874 $87,903 RAID 5 04/01/08 B00028
Sun ST6140 790.67 $67.82 1,675.037 $53,622 RAID 5 02/13/07 B00017
Sun ST2540 735.62 $37.32 2,177.548 $27,451 RAID 5 04/10/07 B00021
IBM DS3400 731.25 $34.36 1,165.933 $25,123 RAID 5 02/27/08 B00027
Sun ST2530 672.05 $26.15 1,451.699 $17,572 RAID 5 08/16/07 B00026
Sun J4200 548.80 $22.92 11,995.295 $12,580 Unprotected 07/10/08 B00033

SPC-2 MBPS = the Performance Metric
$/SPC-2 MBPS = the Price/Performance Metric
ASU Capacity = the Capacity Metric
Data Protection = Data Protection Metric
TSC Price = Total Cost of Ownership Metric
Results Identifier = A unique identification of the result Metric

Complete SPC-2 benchmark results may be found at http://www.storageperformance.org.

Results and Configuration Summary

Storage Configuration:

    30 146.8GB 15K RPM drives (for RAID 5)
    36 146.8GB 15K RPM drives (for RAID 6)
    4 Qlogic HBA

Server Configuration:

    IBM system x3850 M2

Software Configuration:

    MS Win 2003 Server SP2
    SPC-2 benchmark kit

Benchmark Description

The SPC Benchmark-2™ (SPC-2) is a series of related benchmark performance tests that simulate the sequential component of demands placed upon on-line, non-volatile storage in server class computer systems. SPC-2 provides measurements in support of real world environments characterized by:
  • Large numbers of concurrent sequential transfers.
  • Demanding data rate requirements, including requirements for real time processing.
  • Diverse application techniques for sequential processing.
  • Substantial storage capacity requirements.
  • Data persistence requirements to ensure preservation of data without corruption or loss.

Key Points and Best Practices

  • This benchmark was performed using RAID 5 and RAID 6 protection.
  • The controller stripe size was set to 512k.
  • No volume manager was used.

See Also

Disclosure Statement

SPC-2, SPC-2 MBPS, $/SPC-2 MBPS are regular trademarks of Storage Performance Council (SPC). More info www.storageperformance.org. Sun Storage 6180 Array 1,286.74 SPC-2 MBPS, $/SPC-2 MBPS $45.47, ASU Capacity 3,504.693 GB, Protect RAID 6, Cost $58,512.00, Ident. B00044. Sun Storage 6180 Array 1,244.89 SPC-2 MBPS, $/SPC-2 MBPS $42.53, ASU Capacity 3,504.693 GB, Protect RAID 5, Cost $52,951.00, Ident. B00043.

About

BestPerf is the source of Oracle performance expertise. In this blog, Oracle's Strategic Applications Engineering group explores Oracle's performance results and shares best practices learned from working on Enterprise-wide Applications.

Index Pages
Search

Archives
« April 2015
SunMonTueWedThuFriSat
   
1
2
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
  
       
Today